Key takeaways
- The full 5th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals ruled 9-8 on November 20, 2026, that the House violated the Constitution's Quorum Clause when it used proxy votes to pass a $1.7 trillion spending bill in December 2022.
- The practical relief is narrow: the court upheld an injunction that bars the federal government from enforcing the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act against Texas.
- The reasoning could be cited against other provisions of the 2023 omnibus law, although the court did not invalidate them.
- The ruling conflicts with a 2021 D.C. Circuit decision that upheld proxy voting, which leaves open the possibility of Supreme Court review.
The full U.S. Court of Appeals for the 5th Circuit ruled on November 20, 2026, that the House of Representatives unconstitutionally passed a $1.7 trillion government funding bill in 2022. The 9-8 decision held that the pandemic-era proxy voting rule could not establish the quorum the Constitution requires, according to Reuters, as published by NBC News. The House proxy voting ruling carries direct force only against one provision of the law, but it raises questions about how Congress may conduct business.
What did the 5th Circuit decide?
The New Orleans-based court voted 9-8 to uphold an injunction won by Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton, who is leaving office. The injunction blocks enforcement of a provision giving pregnant workers stronger legal protections. That provision, the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act, was part of the spending package, which became the Consolidated Appropriations Act of 2023.

The majority held that the Quorum Clause, which governs how many members must be present for a chamber to do business, does not let absent members be counted through proxies. The Volokh Conspiracy at Reason, which reproduced the opinion, quoted the court: “Proxy presence” does not count. Judge Cory Wilson wrote for the majority, according to coverage compiled by Media Bias News.
The case is Texas v. Blanche, according to Reason. The court recorded 431 votes on the bill. Of those, 205 were cast in person and 226 by proxy. The House clerk’s roll call shows the measure passed 225-201 on December 23, 2022, as reported by Chicago City Wire.
How did House proxy voting work, and why does it matter now?
Proxy voting let a House member who was absent designate a colleague to cast a vote on his or her behalf. Then-Speaker Nancy Pelosi helped put the rule in place in May 2020 as an emergency response to COVID-19. According to Reuters, the House dropped it after Republicans took control following the November 2022 elections. The Senate did not use proxy voting, according to Chicago City Wire.

The ruling matters because the court tied its finding to the passage of the whole bill, not only to the one provision before it. The Washington Times, which framed the decision as a rebuke of Pelosi’s system, reported that the court’s dissenters argued that the Constitution lets each chamber set its own operating rules. Defenders of the ruling and its critics therefore disagree on a central question: how far courts may review a chamber’s internal procedures.
Does the House proxy voting ruling invalidate the whole spending law?
No. The decision does not itself invalidate or enjoin other provisions of the omnibus, and it only stops the federal government from enforcing the pregnancy statute against Texas state agencies. Reuters reported that the relief barred the Justice Department and the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission from enforcing the provision against Texas. The Justice Department, which defended the law, and Paxton’s office did not respond to Reuters’ requests for comment.
Judge James Graves, an appointee of President Barack Obama, dissented. He called the ruling “illogical, inexplicable, and invalid,” and said the majority gave no reason why its holding should reach only a small part of a multitrillion-dollar bill. He also wrote that the Quorum Clause does not require physical presence for a chamber to conduct business, according to Chicago City Wire. Graves noted that more than 99% of House members took part in the vote, including those voting remotely, according to Beinsure.
The Reason post also reproduces an argument that the majority’s logic could support challenges to other parts of the omnibus. Those parts include the ban on TikTok on government devices and the Electoral Count Reform and Presidential Transition Improvement Act. No court has so held, and the majority described its holding as limited, according to the Washington Times.

Could the Supreme Court take up the case?
The ruling sets up a possible conflict with other courts. In 2021 the D.C. Circuit upheld proxy voting in McCarthy v. Pelosi, and the 5th Circuit did not decide whether that earlier case was correct. A three-judge 5th Circuit panel had reached the opposite conclusion in August 2025, according to Hourly Times. That panel ruling was later vacated when the full court agreed to rehear the case, according to SSBCrack News.
The sources reviewed do not report whether the Justice Department or the parties plan to seek Supreme Court review. The House ended proxy voting in January 2023, so there is no current rule for Congress to repeal. That removes the usual legislative fix, according to Karmactive.
The decision lands as lawmakers face a separate funding deadline. Intelligence Report has covered the December 11 shutdown threat and the Iran war funding split in Congress.
What to watch
- A petition to the Supreme Court: Whether the Justice Department or other parties ask the justices to review the case, given the disagreement with the D.C. Circuit.
- Copycat challenges: Whether other litigants cite the Quorum Clause holding against different provisions of the 2023 omnibus law.
- Enforcement against other states: Whether anyone seeks similar relief on the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act outside Texas.
- Congressional reaction: Whether House leaders or committees address the ruling’s effect on how Congress sets its own rules.
- Remote participation proposals: The ruling does not establish that every form of remote participation is unconstitutional, according to a Substack analysis, so future rules could be tested in court.
Frequently asked questions
What did the 5th Circuit rule about House proxy voting?
On November 20, 2026, the full 5th Circuit ruled 9-8 that the Constitution's Quorum Clause does not allow proxies to be counted toward a House quorum. It concluded the House unconstitutionally passed a $1.7 trillion spending bill in December 2022, but it limited relief to enforcement against Texas.
Is the 2022 spending bill now void?
No. The court upheld an injunction that bars the federal government from enforcing the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act against Texas. The decision does not itself invalidate or enjoin other provisions of the omnibus, according to reporting, though dissenters and commentators have noted its reasoning could be cited elsewhere.
Is proxy voting still allowed in the House?
No. The House ended proxy voting in January 2023 after Republicans took the majority. Nancy Pelosi, then Speaker, introduced it in May 2020 as a COVID-19 emergency measure. The 5th Circuit ruling therefore concerns the legality of a past vote, not a current House practice.
Sources
- House unconstitutionally passed spending bill in 2022, appeals court rules (Reuters via NBC News)
- US House unconstitutionally passed spending bill in 2022, court rules (Reuters via The Spokesman-Review)
- En Banc Fifth Circuit Declares House COVID Proxy Voting Rule Unconstitutional (Reason, Volokh Conspiracy)
- Pelosi's pandemic proxy voting scheme in House ruled unconstitutional (The Washington Times)
- Chicago's Davis voted by proxy for spending law Fifth Circuit says lacked a House quorum (Chicago City Wire)
- US House proxy voting ruling finds 2022 spending bill unconstitutional (Karmactive)
- Court Rules House Unconstitutionally Passed 2022 Spending Bill (Hourly Times)
- th Circuit proxy voting ruling finds $1.7 tn spending bill unconstitutional (Beinsure)
Top image: Bobak Ha'Eri / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY 3.0)
This article was produced by the Intelligence Report Desk. Sources are linked below.
