Key takeaways
- Leaders usually have to act when the most decision-relevant variable, such as who will veto, is the one they cannot see.
- Speed matters less than judgment once uncertainty becomes the permanent operating environment rather than a passing shock.
- When a process itself is the obstacle, the most effective leaders change the process rather than repeat the same vote.
- Expedition leadership is a useful analogy for executives and diplomats because it forces explicit triggers for changing course before conditions deteriorate.
The UN Security Council has now held eight informal straw polls for the next secretary-general without producing a consensus candidate, and five veto powers hold the key as Antonio Guterres prepares to leave office. A ninth poll, expected to restore the red ballots, was postponed after members requested more time. Reports conflict on timing: Middle East Eye said the next straw poll would take place on Thursday. Whatever the date, the episode is a live case of leadership under uncertainty, and it is worth reading closely for anyone who has to commit resources before the facts are clear. For the process background, see our earlier piece on the race to clear a veto before Jan. 1.
What does the UN chief race reveal about deciding with incomplete information?
The rules are simple. A candidate needs at least nine of the council’s 15 votes and no veto. The information is not. In the November 5 poll, Costa Rica’s Rebeca Grynspan received 12 “encourage” votes and three “discourage” votes, which looks strong. But that poll used a plain ballot, so it is hard to establish whether the “discourage” votes included any of the five permanent members. The earlier color-coded poll, on October 16, showed that none of the seven candidates had the support of all five permanent members. The late entry of two more candidates split the race further.

The politics behind the blank spaces are real. Russia and the West remain at odds over Ukraine, while Washington has made deep cuts to UN funding and wants a leader who will contain spending. One analyst quoted by Arab News described the situation as “a live bargaining and negotiation right now”. The lesson for executives is that a favorable headline number can be a poor guide when the decisive actors have not shown their hand.
Is speed or judgment worth more when conditions keep shifting?
Corporate research points the same way. Harvard Business Impact’s 2026 study, which surveyed more than 1,100 senior leaders across 15 or more countries, concluded that speed is no longer enough and leaders must bring sharper judgment to decisions made under uncertainty. At the Stockholm Executive Summit 2026, speaker Urban Ahlin offered a simple test: “Good leaders have the ability to change their minds.”

The UN’s own history shows what that looks like. In an earlier deadlock, the council voted 16 times over several weeks without reaching a decision. Then a council president persuaded both candidates to withdraw and devised a straw poll to identify someone none of the major powers would veto. The fix was a change of method, not another round of the same vote. Today the council has not even agreed on how future ballots should be conducted, so the method itself is part of the contest.
What can expedition leadership teach executives and diplomats about risk?
Dylan Welch, founder and CEO of Welch International, which advises governments, companies and multilateral institutions on partnerships and UN engagement, started in the field. He began as a guide and in marketing for EuroAdventures, served as its Rome City Manager from 2012 to 2015, and has led expeditions across Europe, South America and Asia. Expedition leadership is a useful analogy for the Security Council’s problem. A leader is responsible for a group moving through unfamiliar places where conditions can change faster than the plan.
The analytical reading here is ours, not his. Three disciplines carry over to boardrooms and chancelleries:

- Separate what is known from what is assumed. A plain ballot hides the one fact that matters, and a leader should say so openly rather than treat 12 votes as a mandate.
- Set triggers before you need them. Decide in advance what evidence would make you change route, such as a red ballot showing a permanent member’s opposition.
- Keep options open while the group stays aligned. Harvard’s study flags that leadership alignment is a more visible friction point.
Welch International’s documented approach follows a similar logic. It organizes its work into Develop (mapping markets and stakeholders), Partner (building coalitions and guiding engagement with the UN system) and Operate (standing up programs and high-level convenings). It states its principles as trusted access, cross-sector fluency, discretion, execution and senior attention. Mr. Welch also co-hosts, with Emilie McGlone of Peace Boat US, the New York Innovation Forum at 777 United Nations Plaza. The 2026 edition ran on September 21 and 22 during UNGA 81. Rooms like that bring business, government and civil society together before positions harden, which is where uncertainty is cheapest to reduce. Our look at what UNGA week really delivers shows how often the gap between pledges and signed deals comes down to unseen constraints.
What to watch
- The ninth poll. Watch whether it happens this week and whether red ballots return. Color-coded results would show whether Grynspan’s three “discourage” votes include a veto.
- The US position. Washington wants a leader who will contain spending and concentrate on peace and security, and Moscow is reported to favor a successor less critical of its war.
- Process reform. A deal on how ballots are run, or a withdrawal pact like the one in the earlier deadlock, would signal that the council is moving from voting to bargaining.
- The handover date. Guterres leaves at year end, and the General Assembly ultimately has to sign off.
Readers working on partnerships or engagement with the UN system can find more on Welch International’s work at welchinternational.org.
Frequently asked questions
What is leadership under uncertainty?
Leadership under uncertainty means making consequential decisions when key information is missing, outcomes cannot be predicted and conditions keep changing. It relies less on speed than on judgment: distinguishing facts from assumptions, preserving options, setting clear triggers for changing course, and keeping teams or coalitions aligned while new information arrives.
How is the next UN secretary-general chosen?
Under Article 97 of the UN Charter, the General Assembly appoints the secretary-general on the Security Council's recommendation. In practice the council decides, using secret informal straw polls. A candidate needs at least nine of the 15 votes and no veto from the five permanent members: China, France, Russia, the UK and the US.
What does Welch International do?
Welch International is an international relations and communications firm based in St. Petersburg, Florida. It specializes in business development, strategic partnerships and communication strategy across the public sector, the private sector and the multilateral system. Its services are organized as Develop, Partner and Operate, covering market mapping, public-private alliances, UN engagement and high-level convenings.
Sources
- Welch International
- Why the world is still waiting for its next UN secretary-general (Arab News, updated Nov. 17, 2026)
- Why the world is still waiting for its next UN secretary-general (Arab News Pakistan)
- US and rivals spar over next UN boss as race lurches towards deadline (Al Jazeera)
- British MPs urge government to block UAE's Nusseibeh from top UN job (Middle East Eye)
- Deadlock at the Top: The Search for the Next UN Secretary-General (ORF)
- Latest vote shows no candidate for UN chief has the required support of all five key powers (ABC News)
- Global Leadership Study (Harvard Business Impact)
- Leadership when the ground is shifting (Alumni Global)
- Welch International
This article was produced by the Intelligence Report Desk. Sources are linked below.

1 Comment
Pingback: COP31 Overtime: Why Fitness Is a Negotiating Edge When Talks Run Late – Intelligence Report